SUI Symposium All articles
Scholarly Communication

Who Sets the Agenda? Inside the Rise of Participant-Led Scholarly Gatherings

SUI Symposium
Who Sets the Agenda? Inside the Rise of Participant-Led Scholarly Gatherings

Photo: academic unconference participants writing session schedule on paper wall, via c8.alamy.com

On a Saturday morning in a converted warehouse in Pittsburgh, roughly ninety researchers, librarians, and graduate students gathered around a bare wall covered in butcher paper. There was no printed program and no keynote stage. Over the next forty minutes the group built the day's schedule themselves: a doctoral candidate proposed a session on reproducibility tooling, a museum curator offered one on image metadata, and a retired engineer asked whether anyone wanted to discuss funding models for independent laboratories. By early afternoon more than twenty sessions had been posted, merged, and occasionally abandoned. By evening, several had produced shared documents that participants carried home.

The scene is a familiar one to organizers of unconferences, barcamps, and related formats that have quietly spread through American academic life over the past decade and a half. The premise is simple and mildly radical: attendees, not committees, decide what gets discussed.

From Keynote Hall to Blank Wall

The intellectual lineage runs through Open Space Technology, the meeting method Harrison Owen described in the 1980s, and through the technology barcamps that spread across U.S. cities in the mid-2000s. Academic adaptations followed. Digital humanities camps beginning in 2010 brought the model into the humanities; science-communication gatherings, education-focused meetups, and library camps adopted variants; medical educators began running unconference-style sessions inside larger clinical meetings.

What these events share is a procedural commitment rather than a subject matter. Participants arrive without a fixed agenda, pitch topics in a plenary session, and then convene whichever conversations attract an audience. Organizers provide space, food, and a light framework. The content belongs to the room.

The Mechanics of Self-Organization

The operating rules tend to be short. A morning marketplace in which anyone may propose a session. A convention that whoever shows up is the right group. A license to leave a conversation that is not useful, often called the law of two feet. A norm of capturing notes in a shared document so that absent colleagues can follow along.

Those rules matter more than they might appear. Traditional conferences allocate speaking slots months in advance, which rewards seniority and pre-existing networks. A marketplace conducted on the morning of the event rewards topical urgency. A question that became pressing the previous week can find a room; a panel assembled a year earlier cannot.

What Flattening Actually Changes

Advocates point to the visible leveling of status. Graduate students routinely convene sessions attended by department chairs, and the absence of a dais removes some of the ritual distance that shapes question-and-answer periods at conventional meetings. Organizers of several campus-based camps describe the format as a way to surface problems that formal programs cannot accommodate, from the practicalities of data-sharing agreements to the emotional toll of fieldwork.

The leveling is imperfect, and organizers are often candid about it. Confidence is unevenly distributed, and a format that rewards volunteering can amplify existing advantages in gender, seniority, and institutional prestige. Sessions without a designated facilitator can drift toward whoever speaks most readily. Institutional support helps: when a provost's office or a university library absorbs the modest costs, attendance broadens beyond those who can pay their own way.

Documentation presents a second tension. Unconferences rarely generate proceedings, and the knowledge they produce often lives in collaborative notes rather than citable outputs. For early-career scholars whose advancement depends on recognizable forms of credit, that informality can be a genuine cost rather than a virtue.

American Experiments

Several U.S. institutions have made the model a recurring fixture. University libraries have hosted camps on scholarly publishing and digital collections, often at modest expense, with sponsorship from campus research offices. Schools of education have used unconference days to connect practitioners with faculty. Some medical centers have folded short participant-driven blocks into larger clinical symposia, using them to discuss implementation problems that formal abstracts rarely capture.

The pandemic years pushed many of these gatherings online, and organizers learned something useful in the process. A marketplace conducted over video, with topic pitches posted to a shared board, can work reasonably well and can widen participation to people who cannot travel. Hybrid versions have persisted, though most organizers report that the informal corridor conversations, the true engine of the format, resist translation to a screen.

Where the Model Stops

The unconference is not a substitute for the large disciplinary meeting, and it does not pretend to be. It lacks scale, an exhibition floor, a recruitment pipeline, and the archival function that proceedings provide. It depends heavily on skilled facilitation, which is a craft rather than an accident, and it can become insular when a recurring cast of participants sets the tone.

There is also the matter of what such gatherings are asked to fix. Flattening a program does not flatten a profession. Salary disparities, hiring precarity, and uneven access to travel funding persist inside the most egalitarian room.

The Signal Beneath the Format

What the unconference ultimately reveals is less about meetings than about scholarly communication itself. Researchers have been saying for years that the most valuable part of a conference is the conversation in the hallway. Participant-driven formats simply take that claim seriously and build an event around it.

That is a useful provocation for the institutions that run conventional conferences. A mixed model may prove the more durable answer: a formal program for the record, a self-organized track for the present, and an honest accounting of who can afford to attend either. The blank wall with the butcher paper is not a rejection of scholarly gatherings. It is a reminder of what they were for.

All Articles

Related Articles

Outside the Citadel: How Grassroots Scholar Networks Are Redefining Academic Authority

Outside the Citadel: How Grassroots Scholar Networks Are Redefining Academic Authority

Gatekeepers or Bottlenecks? Rethinking Peer Review in an Era of Urgent Science

Gatekeepers or Bottlenecks? Rethinking Peer Review in an Era of Urgent Science

Reclaiming the Archive: Scholar-Led Publishing and the Fight to Democratize Academic Knowledge

Reclaiming the Archive: Scholar-Led Publishing and the Fight to Democratize Academic Knowledge